• Trust Weighted
    OK
  • 26
    Trust Points

BrianSez's Review

Summary - Pretty Bad 1.5

A widow (Hilary Swank) gets messages from her deceased husband that help her through her rough time. Despite funny moments, touching scenes, and and a very decent cast, the movie ended up being a little too sappy and boring for me.

Acting - Barely OK 2.0

Hilary Swank did not come across all that funny or sad when the moment called. I think that Lisa Kudrow was the funniest of all the cast. The Irish husband (Gerard Butler) was Ok. Harry Connick Jr? Um, they could have found someone much better. Really – I don’t think the cast did a bad job — they were just, well, uninspiring.

Male Stars - Barely OK 2.0

Female Stars - Barely OK 2.0

Female Costars - Barely OK 2.0

Male Costars - Barely OK 2.0

Film - Bad 1.0

Overly long setups and a story that is just not believable detract from the drama and romantic comedy.

Direction - Bad 1.0

Dialogue - Bad 1.0

Music - Bad 1.0

Visuals - Bad 1.0

Edge - Tame 1.3

Sex Innocent 1.3

Violence Gentle 1.3

Rudeness Polite 1.3

Reality - Surreal 2.6

Circumstantial - Surreal 2.6

Biological - Surreal 2.6

Physical - Surreal 2.6

More reviews on P.S. I Love You More reviews by BrianSez

© 2006-2025 WikPik, Inc. All rights reserved.

Go to the full ViewGuide