• Trust Weighted
    Very Good
  • 66
    Trust Points

Wick's Review

Summary - Very Good 3.5 click to collapse contents 

A tremendous cast makes short work of an overwrought but underdone story in Broken City. Crowe, Wahlberg and Zeta-Jones are the single-namers, and Kyle Chandler should be. They’re not all. The strong supporting cast includes Barry Pepper, luscious Natalie Martinez and engaging newcomer Britney Theriot.

Russell Crowe plays the Mayor of New York like a Godfather in pinstripes, at daggers with Katherine Zeta-Jones as his wife, and a hero to the gay community. The Mayor sacks Mark Wahlberg’s NYPD Detective after a good kill gone bad, then brings him back seven years later to get incriminating pics on his wife, who’s apparently sleeping with Kyle Chandler. Great setup, that. Great climax to follow? Not so much.

Broken City’s arch dialog occasionally crosses over into melodrama and its action never gets above parboil, even as this aspiring action movie affects an old school hard-boil, an attitude not easily pulled off these days. Thus its reach exceeds its grasp, even if that grasp is often impressively powerful.

For fans of the davvero grande cast, NYC movies, old school political thrillers and two-fisted private eye stories, Broken City mostly works. More panned than praised by the professional critics, it delivers better than most politicians do, even if that’s a low bar these days.

Acting - Great 4.0 click to expand contents 

Film - Very Good 3.5 click to expand contents 

Edge - Sordid 3.1 click to expand contents 

Reality - Surreal 2.5 click to expand contents 

More reviews on Broken City More reviews by Wick