• Trust Weighted
    Really Great
  • 5
    Trust Points

JesseLiberty's Review

Summary - Really Great 4.5

Brilliant vehicle for Gene Hackman as the grizzled, experience-hardened commander of a nuclear sub brought into existential conflict with Denzel Washington cast as the embodiment of the “new navy” – trained to be 100% professional but with no combat experience. The sub receives an order to fire its missiles during a time of heightened tension, but then is cut off before receiving either confirmation or the order to stand down. Hackman feels sufficient urgency to bend the rules; Washington is forced into direct conflict and the crew is caught between them.

Acting - Really Great 4.5

Male Stars - Perfect 5.0

This film lives or dies on the acting of the two stars; and they are each brilliant; if anything they enhance one another's performance.

Female Stars - Perfect 5.0

There are none (set at 5 to keep the overall score appropriate)

Female Costars - Perfect 5.0

There are none (set at 5 to keep the overall score appropriate)

Male Costars - Great 4.0

The co-stars aren't called upon to do much, but the few confrontations that involve the crew are blisteringly tense and believable.

Film - Great 4.0

Not for one moment do you doubt you are on the sub.

Direction - Perfect 5.0

The tension is never let up, the pacing is perfect, the cinematography is beautiful and never gets in the way.

Dialogue - Perfect 5.0

Some of the best writing in any thriller I've seen

Music - Very Good 3.5

Not memorable, nor intrusive

Visuals - Great 4.0

Total immersion experience

Edge - Risqué 1.9

Sex Innocent 1.1

Not a factor

Violence Gentle 1.4

The violence is psychological; not physical

Rudeness Profane 3.1

Exactly appropriate to the circumstances

Reality - Glib 1.5

Circumstantial - Surreal 2.5

You have to accept the premise, that the order to launch would be given in the first place under the conditions they describe. Not a fatal weakness, but not totally convincing.

Biological - Natural 1.0

Physical life aboard the sub feels right, at least to one who has never done it.

Physical - Natural 1.0

Once you accept the circumstances, everything else falls into place
More reviews on Crimson Tide More reviews by JesseLiberty

© 2006-2024 WikPik, Inc. All rights reserved.

Go to the full ViewGuide